Politics and Medicine - Choosing Brain Surgeons and Presidents

Fortunately, I haven't had to choose a brain surgeonrebuild your car's engine or a wise leader to run the
yet. But, if I did I would have a careful list of criteriacountry, don't you think experience counts?
that would need to be met. That list would takeExperentia docet (experience teaches) is the Latin
several things into account.phrase I still remember from High School, back when
-What training, where and by whom has the individualwe still had the opportunity to learn the dead
had?language.
-How long has he/she been at it?Of course, experience alone is not the only criteria.
-What is his/her reputation among peers?As I have pointed out above, a brain surgeon needs
-What is his/her bedside manner?to bring skill, but also patience, and kindness, and
-How does he/she deal with my questions andpreparation and insight and knowledge and wisdom
concerns?and forthrightness and sensitivity and hope. It seems
Finally, what about EXPERIENCE?these are qualities useful in a politician as well.
David Brooks, a columnist with the New York Times,Probably one of the most important characteristics is
pointed out in his editorial yesterday that "...theto be able to be honest and straight forward, to tell
founders used the word "experience" 91 times in thethe truth to me, when I need to hear it. While I may
Federalist papers." He pointed out that "democracy isnot like the message, I would surely appreciate and
not average people selecting average leaders. It isrespect having someone tell me what I need to
average people with the wisdom to select the bestknow. I am perfectly capable acting on that
prepared." Sound counsel!information.
So when selecting a brain surgeon or a mechanic to